
Understanding the differences between ETFs and Mutual Funds
Exchange-traded funds (ETFs) and mutual funds are often discussed as competing investment philosophies, but in reality, they are simply different structures for delivering investment strategies. Think of them as traveling along the same road, but in slightly different cars.
What are they?
Both ETFs and mutual funds are commingled vehicles, meaning investors purchase a percentage of an underlying portfolio rather than investing in individual securities. This approach provides greater diversification than investing in individual stocks or bonds and differs from separately managed accounts (SMA), where investors own the underlying securities directly.
Both vehicles offer passive or active management options, as well as broad or highly specialized exposures. While the fund structure, or “wrapper” matters, it’s often the characteristics of the underlying portfolio that play a bigger role in investment outcomes. The most meaningful differences tend to emerge around trading, taxes, costs, liquidity, and implementation. Rather than asking whether ETFs or mutual funds are “better,” investors should consider which structure best fits their strategy, account type, and intended use within the portfolio.
Trading mechanics: Flexibility vs. simplicity
There are significant differences in how ETFs and mutual funds trade:
- Mutual funds transact once per day at their closing Net Asset Value (NAV), the price per share set after the close of the trading day. Every shareholder trading on a given day receives the same NAV.
- ETFs trade throughout the day at market prices, which may be at a premium or discount to NAV, depending on trading dynamics. This intraday trading gives ETF investors greater flexibility, but also introduces bid/ask spreads (the gap between buy and sell prices) and the possibility of trading away from NAV.
The value of intraday liquidity depends on how the investment is being used. Liquidity is a feature, but not every long-term investor needs it. For example, workplace retirement accounts like 401(k)s typically hold mutual funds rather than ETFs due to the intraday pricing issue.
Costs: Look beyond the expense ratio
ETFs have often had lower expense ratios, but this gap has narrowed in recent years. As of December 31, 2025, the average equity index mutual fund expense ratio was 0.05%, in line with equity index ETFs.1 On average, fees for active ETFs tend to be lower than for mutual funds (0.44% vs. 0.64%, respectively), though fees for both have declined. Beyond expense ratios, investors should consider transaction fees, platform fees, share class differences, and possible bid/ask spreads in ETF trading. In other words, the cheapest-looking vehicle is not necessarily the cheapest to own or trade.
Taxes: Where the ETF structure can matter
How the vehicles are traded affects their tax efficiency:
- Mutual funds generally transact in cash. When an investor sells shares, the portfolio manager may sell securities to raise cash for the redemption, leading to capital gains or losses in the portfolio. At year-end, capital gains are distributed to all shareholders.
- ETFs are publicly traded, like individual stocks, so investors sell to other buyers on the exchange with no positions needing to be sold within the fund for this transaction to occur. This avoids realization of capital gains for remaining shareholders—a major difference from mutual funds.
To take this one level further, ETF managers can accommodate investment flows by creating or redeeming “creation units,” which are baskets of assets that represent the entirety of the ETF’s exposure. As a result, investors are typically not exposed to capital gains within the underlying structure, making ETFs more tax-efficient, especially in tax-advantaged accounts such as IRAs or 401(k)s.
Liquidity
ETF liquidity is determined not by trading volume alone, but also by the liquidity of the underlying securities and the ability to create and redeem units. For instance, a low-volume ETF holding highly liquid large-cap stocks may still be easy to trade. Conversely, wrapping illiquid securities in an ETF does not make them inherently liquid.
ETF liquidity and underlying market liquidity are distinct concepts: an ETF cannot magically transform illiquid securities into liquid ones.
Transparency
ETFs generally disclose their holdings more frequently than mutual funds, offering additional transparency that can aid portfolio construction and overall exposure analysis. However, this transparency can create challenges for some active managers concerned about trading or intellectual property.
Implementation: Where mutual funds could have an advantage
While ETFs are efficient from an after-tax perspective, mutual funds offer unique implementation features. When closing a fund, mutual funds can “soft close,” allowing existing investors to continue contributing, or “hard close,” where no new investments are allowed. This can be a benefit in smaller market segments (such as micro-cap or small-cap equities) where managers may intentionally cap assets to preserve the ability to invest in smaller companies. Investors using automatic portfolio contributions and withdrawals may also prefer mutual funds, because exact dollar investing can be more straightforward, hence their use in retirement plans.
Strategy first, vehicle second
Ultimately, the most important part of investing is determining your investment objective and desired exposure. Strategies should be evaluated based on their process, portfolio characteristics, and total cost. Then, the decision of vehicle, whether an ETF or mutual fund, should be made for the best outcome. The vehicle should serve the investment thesis, not become the investment thesis.
1 ICI.

Related insights and perspectives
Economic and Financial Markets Outlook: Fourth Quarter 2026




